More
Сhoose
Texas

8350 N Central Expy
Suite 1900
Dallas, TX 75206

469.205.1600

Colorado

1630 Welton St.
Denver, CO 80202

720.571.8942

Brett Ordiway Quoted in The Dallas Morning News: Breaking Down Karmelo Anthony’s New Trial Hearing

Category: Media
Date: August 21, 2026
Author: Brett Ordiway

Ordiway PLLC founding attorney Brett Ordiway was quoted by The Dallas Morning News this week ahead of the Karmelo Anthony new trial hearing, offering expert analysis on the compressed timeline and steep legal hurdles facing Anthony’s appellate team.

Note: The Dallas Morning News article is behind a paywall. Read the full article here.

Anthony, 19, was convicted in June of murdering 17-year-old Austin Metcalf during an altercation at a Frisco track meet and sentenced to 35 years in prison. His appellate team filed a motion for a new trial shortly after sentencing, setting off a strict 75-day clock under Texas law.

The hearing was scheduled for August 20, leaving the presiding judge just three days to issue a ruling before the motion would be automatically denied.

Ordiway, speaking to The Dallas Morning News as an outside expert not involved in the case, described the situation plainly:

“If the recusal motion is granted, then that is going to be a very quick turnaround.”

Anthony’s attorneys built their case around three main arguments: that Judge John Roach Jr. improperly restricted courtroom access during trial, that jury instructions limited jurors from fully considering Anthony’s self-defense claim, and that prosecutors broke an informal agreement over what evidence could be raised at trial.

On the question of who the defense should call to testify at the hearing, Ordiway was direct:

“The obvious candidates are Karmelo himself and his trial attorneys, because they’re the only ones who really understand what happened there.”

As for the odds of a new trial being granted, Ordiway was candid about the difficulty of the standard:

“Just as the court is going to want to make sure that he got the process due to him, the court also is not going to want to overrule the jury’s verdict in this case unless it has a very, very good reason to do so.”

He put the odds of success as “very low” — consistent with the broader reality that motions for new trials are rarely granted in Texas courts.

If the motion is denied, the case moves to the Fifth Court of Appeals in Dallas, where many of the same issues would be relitigated over a much longer timeline. Ordiway noted that given the complexity of the record, the court likely won’t have the required material from both sides until early 2027.

“That’ll be a long road ahead there,” he said.

Read the full Dallas Morning News article here (subscriber access required)

Brett Ordiway is a board-certified criminal appellate attorney at Ordiway PLLC, handling direct appeals, habeas corpus applications, and post-conviction matters in Texas state and federal courts. If you are facing a criminal appeal, contact our firm to discuss your case.

Posted in Media
Previous
All posts
Next